The New York Yankees traded 2022 All-Star catcher Jose Trevino to the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for relief pitcher Fernando Cruz, freeing up $3.5 million in salary. The Reds subsequently signed Trevino to a three-year contract extension worth around $15 million. While Trevino’s performance had been declining, his defensive skills and experience made him a valuable asset for the Reds. The Yankees’ decision to let him go has left fans questioning their evaluation of his value.
The New York Yankees made several roster moves this offseason, including trading away 2022 All-Star catcher Jose Trevino to the Cincinnati Reds. This decision has left many Yankees fans scratching their heads, especially after the Reds recently signed Trevino to a three-year contract extension worth around $15 million.
The Trade and Its Aftermath
The trade that sent Trevino to the Reds in exchange for relief pitcher Fernando Cruz was initially seen as a strategic move by the Yankees. It allowed them to add bullpen depth and free up about $3.5 million in salary, which was Trevino’s expected arbitration figure. However, the Reds’ decision to sign Trevino to a significant contract extension has raised questions about the Yankees’ evaluation of his value.
Trevino’s Declining Performance
While Yankees fans appreciated Trevino’s contributions, his performance had been on the decline. His batting average regressed, and his arm strength suffered due to shoulder issues. The Yankees, facing financial constraints and needing to clear salary space, decided not to retain him for $3.5 million in 2025. The Reds, on the other hand, saw enough potential in Trevino to invest $15 million in him.
The Reds’ Perspective
The Reds, a small-market team, may have seen value in Trevino’s experience and defensive skills. Despite his declining offensive numbers, Trevino remains one of the best defensive catchers in the league, excelling in categories like blocks above average and pitch framing. The Reds might also be looking to secure a veteran presence to mentor their younger players.
The Contract Details
According to Jon Heyman, the Reds agreed to a three-year extension with Trevino, totaling nearly $15 million, with a club option for an additional year. This move has left many Yankees fans wondering why their team didn’t invest $3.5 million to retain Trevino for one more season, especially with no clear backup catcher options.
What’s Next
As the season approaches, the Yankees will need to find a suitable backup catcher, while Trevino will look to prove his worth with the Reds. The Reds’ investment in Trevino could be a strategic move to secure a veteran presence and mentor their younger players. Only time will tell if this decision pays off for both teams.
Bottom Line
The New York Yankees’ decision to trade away Jose Trevino has been met with mixed reactions, especially after the Reds signed him to a $15 million contract extension. While the Yankees needed to clear salary space and add bullpen depth, the Reds saw value in Trevino’s defensive skills and experience. As both teams prepare for the upcoming season, the impact of this decision will be closely watched.
