With Gerrit Cole facing possible Tommy John surgery due to an elbow injury, the Yankees are actively seeking elite starting pitchers. They are pursuing a trade for White Sox ace Dylan Cease, offering Clarke Schmidt in return. Efforts to acquire Sandy Alcantara have been thwarted, as the Marlins declared him unavailable.
Read Full Story Here –
The New York Yankees are confronting a significant challenge as their ace, Gerrit Cole, faces the prospect of Tommy John surgery due to an elbow injury. This development has intensified the team’s search for top-tier starting pitchers to maintain their competitive edge in the upcoming season.
Gerrit Cole’s Elbow Injury
Gerrit Cole has been diagnosed with nerve inflammation and edema in his elbow, leading to a recommendation for Tommy John surgery—a procedure that would sideline him for an extended period. This situation has left a substantial void in the Yankees’ rotation, prompting urgent considerations for reinforcement.
Pursuing Dylan Cease

In response to Cole’s potential absence, the Yankees have intensified their pursuit of Chicago White Sox ace Dylan Cease. Cease, who delivered a 14-11 record with a 3.47 ERA in 33 starts during the 2024 season, is under club control for one more year. The proposed trade package includes Yankees pitcher Clarke Schmidt, who posted a 5-5 record with a 2.85 ERA in 16 starts last season. This potential acquisition aims to bolster the Yankees’ rotation amidst Cole’s uncertain status.
Considering Sandy Alcantara
Another potential target is Miami Marlins’ ace Sandy Alcantara. However, recent reports indicate that the Marlins have informed Alcantara he will not be traded, making this option less viable for the Yankees.
Impact on the Yankees’ Season
The potential loss of Gerrit Cole significantly impacts the Yankees’ aspirations for the season. Securing a top-tier replacement like Dylan Cease is crucial to maintaining their competitiveness in a highly challenging division. The front office’s decisions in the coming weeks will be pivotal in shaping the team’s trajectory for the 2025 season.